Friday, April 20, 2018

Echoes of Younger Brother in Lee Harvey Oswald

So, being the hyper-race-focused social justice warrior that I am, I took note of the few characters of color that appear in the novel. Not to take note of how many there were but rather to analyze what role they might play and therefore how DeLillo (or Oswald) might view the issue of race in the context of Oswald's broader arc towards becoming Kennedy's (supposed) assassin. (Also, I'm specifically looking at Lee's arc since I want to see what race reveals about him as a character.)

It seems relevant to the time period to discuss questions of race. The Civil Rights Movement was just picking up steam, we had troops stationed in various Asian countries creating xenophobic tensions, and, as Libra discusses, we're not exactly on the best terms with Cuba. Not to mention that Kennedy was seen by many to be a champion of civil rights, integration, and racial equality (though we can debate to what extent that was actually true.)

The first time we see any mention of race in Lee's half of the book is when he's bullied for sitting with the black people in the back of the bus. However, before you get any ideas about Oswald's noble intentions, DeLillo makes sure to note that it's not clear whether Oswald did it out of principle or ignorance    Already that gives an odd feeling to the reader. If he had done it out of principle, we would likely respect and admire that, and perceive it as a quality befitting of a budding revolutionary like the one he fancies himself to be. If he had done it out of ignorance, one might merely chuckle at how he stumbled onto a social issue. But the real cause, just wanting to piss people off? That's stupid. Irritatingly stupid. He simply uses the nearest and most convenient situation to advance his narrative as a Real Edgy Boy, paying no mind to the black people as people, specifically people subject to an inhumane system.

Oswald's next interaction with a person of color isn't until his adventures in Japan, where he comes across Konno. I'm not gonna lie, the depiction of Konno made me somewhat uncomfortable. Some parts were charming and nice, seeing Oswald having a friend that he can talk to communism about and feel comfortable with. But Konno plays an age-old classic among older Asian men in Western literature: The Mr. Miyagi, the sage, beard-stroking, fascinating Asian man meant to educate our coming-of-age Western protagonist on the ways of his exotic Oriental world so that the protagonist might discover himself. Not a person in his own right, Konno is instead reduced to his usefulness to Oswald. Again, we see a person of color being used as a mere vehicle for Oswald's ultimate "more important" character arc, with little of his own personality. Oswald even says that he never actually feels like he's talking to a person when he's talking to Konno, that Konno just acts as something he can feed all his thoughts into.

(Also supplementing this dehumanization of Konno is the weird exoticization and sexualization of East Asianness, as some sort of freaky universe to go wild in for a night or two, as if the people in it are utterly alien.)

Oswald's next interaction with a person of color (and his first antagonistic one) is his fight with Rodriguez. (It should be noted that it's not explicitly stated that Rodriguez isn't white, but for my purposes, I'm gonna assume he is.) Like the black people on the bus and Konno before him, Rodriguez acts as a plot vehicle, the only distinction being that this time he's working against Oswald instead of for him.  Oswald sees Rodriguez as a symbolic villain, a way to advance his cause for his "rights" despite the extremely petty nature of the argument he instigates.

The first time Oswald encounters a person of color that isn't a plot vehicle is his cellmate Bobby Dupard in the brig. He expects Dupard to function much in the same way as Konno, even saying that he wishes "for an experienced perspective, for the knowledge of some grizzled figure with kind and tired eyes, a counselor, wise to the game." Again, he wishes for a person of color to guide him and advance his own narrative arc. But Dupard, who is justifiably mostly concerned with his own survival, lacks the capability to give a shit about Oswald. And so Oswald, who has come to expect Dumbledorean figures out of men of color, isn't sure what to make of Dupard. The first person of color that works for themselves instead of for Oswald confuses Oswald since he's so used to having them serve his arc.

All of this is reminiscent of Younger Brother from Doctorow's Ragtime, who I would argue similarly saw people like Coalhouse, Emma Goldman, Evelyn, and Mexican revolutionaries as mere narrative vehicles for his story, completely disposing of their humanity.  And it makes sense that Oswald's narrative would parallel Younger Brother's. One of our major complaints about Younger Brother (or one of mine anyway) was that he never really gave a shit about the causes he participates in, he just wants to belong to something bigger than himself. Someone focused only on belonging will ultimately care little for the struggles of the people he claims to fight for as a communist, only temporarily allying with them so that he can "grow" as a person.

5 comments:

  1. I wouldn't say Lee is being described as a racist. Whether or not he sat in a bus with blacks to piss people off, he still did it and had no qualms about it. I'd also say that it can't be generalized that all people of colour are used to drive Lee's story arc for two reasons. First, as you pointed out, Dupard isn't as much. While Lee does want him to be an experienced guide for him, he wants that more because he thinks his life in jail is important if he's going to follow in the footsteps of Stalin and Lenin, not because Dupard is black. Second, every character Lee interacts with is supposed to shape him more than be an actual character. That's the whole point of writing about Oswald: we are to see how he became an assassin.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This is a really interesting connection you've drawn, and I totally agree with it. Both Mother's Younger Brother and Lee seem to just join causes that, as you say, cement them as "Real Edgy Boys," regardless of the actual people in the organization, even if they're fighting for their basic human rights. I think it's a pretty sick thing to do, since it actually ends up being pretty dehumanizing to anybody that they decide to subject to their needs.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I agree that there are elements of the "inscrutable" and exotic but wise Easterner in the depiction of Konno, which fits with Lee's fascination with Tokyo "floating world" culture more generally. But he's a lot more ambiguous than casting him as a "Mr. Miyagi" might suggest--he's a lot younger, his political views are radical and contemporary (focused on U.S. interventions in Asian politics), and it's less clear that he actually has as much influence as Lee seems to think he does. He fits the paradigm of the cool and worldly older friend in college as well. We should also remember that Lee is a 17-year-old kid who's never been outside of the U.S. before--of course Tokyo nightlife will be overwhelming, exotic, and fascinating for him.

    Similarly, Dupard is sort of cast (by Lee himself) in the "wizened old con" role (like Morgan Freeman in _Shawshank Redemption_?), but DeLillo undermines this "casting," as it becomes unclear how "wise" he actually is. Lee keeps trying to make his experiences fit into these conventional narratives, but it's not clear that the other characters are always going to cooperate.

    Keep an eye on Bobby Dupard, though. We're not done with him in this novel.

    ReplyDelete
  4. When Bobby comes back to be part of the plan to kill General Walker, he seems more competent than Lee. He's the one who notices that it's April 10 instead of the intended April 17. But Lee forces him into manning the getaway car instead of taking the shot. To some extent, Lee treats everyone that way, regardless of race, since he must be the pure revolutionary.

    -Reed

    ReplyDelete
  5. I don't buy the claim that Konno is portrayed as a Mr. Miyagi figure overall. Also, while Lee may look to Dupard for guidance, he isn't really given any. Also, I don't think that Younger Brother didn't care for any cause, and isn't really similar to Lee in that way.

    ReplyDelete

(I TALK ABOUT TRUMP IN THIS POST) Modern Postmodernism

This post isn't strictly about Libra, more about this course in general (but it'll tie back to Libra eventually probably somehow.) ...